Alien invaders or home-grown thugs?

"All plants move, but they don't usually pull themselves out of the ground and chase you

 So begins the 1962 film adaptation of John Wyndham’s classic catastrophe novel, Day of the Triffids, in which humanity is overwhelmed by an invasion of deadly whip-wielding weeds.

Triffids may not be real but fears about invasive weeds most definitely are.

Day of the Triffids film poster

We’ve touched on the complexity of naming a plant a “weed” in our What is a weed anyway? campaign, and we’ve discovered that there are benefits to many of these plants. But there’s no denying that there are some weeds that can cause harm to our environment.

“Invasive Alien Species” are recognised under international law as one of the greatest threats to global biodiversity, human well-being and prosperity.

They are blamed for crowding out native species, degrading ecosystems and driving extinctions, with an enormous economic cost estimated at £1.7 billion per year in the UK alone [1].

While there is good evidence that invasive alien species can cause significant harm, it has also been argued that the risks have been overstated and reveal as much about our own prejudices and preferences as the species themselves.

Common poppy

Native species are those that arrived in an area without human intervention. Alien species are those introduced by people, intentionally or otherwise, at some point in the past. In the UK, we typically divide alien plants into two categories.

Archeophytes (“ancient plants”) were brought here before 1500 CE, often thousands of years ago, and include familiar weeds and wildflowers like poppies (Papaver rhoeas), cornflowers (Centaurea cyanus) and scentless mayweed (Tripleurospermum inodorum).

Neophytes (“new plants”) arrived more recently and include the butterfly bush (Buddleja) and Rhododendron.

Definitions of “invasive” vary, but generally include plant species able to spread and cause damage to native habitats or natural processes on which people depend.

Japanese knotweed

The best-known invasive alien plant species in the UK is undoubtedly Japanese knotweed (Reynoutria japonica), which has spread relentlessly since it was introduced as a garden plant in the nineteenth century.

Japanese knotweed has dense leaves that crowd out other plants and has  exceptionally strong stems and creeping roots able to undermine foundations and walls, lift pavements and fracture drains. This damage is estimated to cost the British economy £166 million each year [1], with huge sums spent on control and eradication programmes that have, overall, failed to prevent the continued spread of the species throughout the UK.

Like any weed, Japanese knotweed has done well because we have provided the perfect conditions for it to thrive. Rough ground around our railways, roads, rivers, industrial sites and neglected parks mimic its native home in disturbed volcanic habitats in China and Japan, with plenty of opportunities for root fragments to break off and be spread by rivers or the illegal movement of infested soil.

Japanese knotweed is a classic example of a weed being “a plant in the wrong place”. In its native Japanese volcanic habitat knotweed is kept in check by repeated coverings of volcanic ash and landslides that limit the plants growth. It grows as part of an ecosystem of similarly vigorous plants and is surrounded by natural pests, that all work to stop it from becoming the destructive weed it is here in the UK.

Cornflowers

Aggressive species like Japanese knotweed make headlines, but not all alien plants become invasive. There are hundreds of introduced species in the UK that don’t cause significant problems. In fact, many archeophyte plants were once regarded as a major threat to agriculture, but modern farming practices mean many have become extremely rare and are subject to intensive conservation and restoration efforts.

The cornflower was one such weed, as observed by the poet John Clare in 1825.

…. the blue corn bottles crowding their splendid colours in large sheets over the land and ‘troubling the cornfields’ with destroying beauty.

Cornflower populations have since declined drastically in the wild leading it to be classified as ‘Endangered’ for a time.

While some neophytes like Japanese knotweed are undoubtedly problematic, less competitive species have arguably become positive additions to the UK flora.

For example, snowdrops (Galanthus) seem so at home in our hedgerows and woods that they are often assumed to be native and are one of our most loved and easily-recognised wildflowers.

Sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus) is another neophyte often assumed to be a UK native and is valued for its ability to provide shelter in exposed coastal and hilltop areas. Sycamore trees are also controlled as a weed in some semi-natural woodlands.

So the extent to which alien plants are viewed as invasive is linked partly to their natural ability to spread, but also to where they occur and how useful or beautiful they are perceived to be.

Tor grassBrachypodium pinnatum © Stefan Lefnaer

Native plants are rarely described as invasive, but they too can spread to dominate and damage habitats.

For example, tor grass (Brachypodium pinnatum) has become a significant problem in chalk grassland, creating dense, spreading patches that are disliked by grazing animals and crowd out less competitive plants. Like Japanese knotweed, tor grass is taking advantage of its situation, where reduced grazing has provided an opportunity for the unrestricted growth.

There are other potentially problematic native species, including bracken (Pteridium aquilinum), that spreads rapidly in woods and moorland to crowd out surrounding vegetation, and birch trees (Betula), that can quickly colonise heathland.

Bracken

It is a mistake to assume all alien plants are bad and all native plants are good in all situations, but there are good reasons for considering the two groups differently.

Alien species have left behind the competing plants, animals, parasites and pathogens that would naturally keep them in check, giving them a competitive advantage if the growing conditions are good compared with native and longstanding ancient plants that have grown up with our ecosystems.

Many alien arrivals will have little impact, but our ecosystem is complex, where the long-term consequences of new introductions are hard to predict and even harder to put right when things go wrong.

Close up of bright yellow corn marigolds and purple blue cornflowers in a field

It is therefore sensible to follow the precautionary approach that guides nature conservation in general. We should always minimise risks to the environment, even if we are not sure exactly how great these risks are.

This means never introducing plants to existing natural areas, particularly nature reserves or sites containing rare species and habitats, unless this is being done under expert ecological supervision.

We should think carefully about whether the plants in our gardens, parks and other green spaces are at risk of escape and make sure we manage and dispose of potentially invasive material responsibly.

Detailed guidance from the RHS and Plantlife on gardening without invasive plants can be found here, including a list of native and non-native species that are unlikely to jump the garden fence.

Finally, find a space for UK native weeds and wildflowers in your life. They look beautiful, benefit wildlife and definitely won’t chase you down the street!

 

Read more from our What is a Weed Anyway? campaign here

 

[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298559361_The_Economic_Cost_of_...